Use of Cytokeratin 17 in the Differentiation Between Desmoplastic Trichilemmoma and Cutaneous Basal Cell Carcinoma

Desmoplastic trichilemmoma (DTL) is a variant of trichilemmoma characterized by a prominent desmoplastic stroma that may mimic invasive carcinoma. These lesions typically show features of a conventional trichilemmoma at the periphery, surrounding dense hyalinized stroma with entrapped cords of tumor cells. On a small or superficial biopsy, DTL may pose a diagnostic challenge in distinguishing this benign adnexal neoplasm from invasive carcinoma, particularly basal cell carcinoma (BCC). We aimed to investigate whether the immunohistochemical expression of cytokeratin 17 (CK17) would be useful in the differentiation between DTL and BCC. CK17 is expressed in normal adnexal structures and has been shown to demonstrate strong staining in BCCs. Expression of CK17 was examined in 23 cases of DTL and 23 BCCs. An immunoreactivity score was assigned using the percentage of tumor cells staining with scoring as follows: 0, complete negativity; 1, < 15% tumor cells staining; 2, 15%-84% tumor cells staining; and 3, >85% staining. All cases of BCC scored as 3, whereas 18% of DTL scored as 3. The mean percent staining for CK17 was significantly higher for BCCs (97% of tumor cells) than DTLs (57% of tumor cells); P < 0.001 in the unpaired t test. The pattern of CK17 staining may also help differentiate between cases scoring 3. All BCCs showed strong diffuse staining throughout, whereas for those cases of DTL with a score of 3, the peripheral basaloid rim in the tumor lobules did not stain. CK17 is a useful adjunct in distinguishing DTL from BCC in small or superficial biopsy specimens.